Gules and Sable

From SCA Heraldry Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

WARNING: Do not cite this page as a reference. This page is on this wiki only to make the content "searchable" and easier to find. If you find the information you seek here, go to the original sources to verify the information and use them for your documentation.

Basic Information:

Many combinations of gules and sable (red and black), especially gules on sable and sable on gules, would be considered low Contrastand would be un-registerable using the Core Style rules. They would have to be registered as an Individually Attested Pattern formerly known as a Regional Style Exception.

See SENA - http://heraldry.sca.org/sena.html#A4%7Chttp:heraldry.sca.org/sena.html#A4

Blog with collection of IAP submissions from January 2007 through October 2020 - http://blog.heraldicart.org/catalog-of-iap-submissions/

Period Examples:

Form to add new examples to the Tincture IAP Spreadsheet:

Anglo-French:

Nothalten, a municipality in the canton of Barr in France: Gules a bear sable on a trimount issuant from base vert, maintaining an anchor with the top forming the numeral 4 Or. http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nothalten

Insignia Insignia BSB
Insignia Anglica, 16th c. BSB 291, f35r, Bodyam Insignia Anglica, 16th c. BSB 291, f36r, Cobelegh BSB 291, f44v, Insignia Anglica, 16th C

Academy of Saint Gabriel report 1991 ( http://www.s-gabriel.org/1991) gives a few examples of low-contrast gyronny:

  • Mathison (1639) Gyronny sable and gules a lion rampant Or [4]; ...
  • Guild of Coopers (1509) Gyronny sable and gules on a chevron between three annulets Or a royne between two broad axes azure, and on a chief vert three lilies argent [5]; [see below for illustrations]
  • Nisbet, Alexander, _A System of Heraldry_ (Edinburgh: T.A. Constable, 1984), v.1, p.198.
  • Bromley, John, and Heather Child, _The Armorial Bearings of the Guilds of London_ (New York: Frederick Warne & Co. Inc., 1960).
WorshipfulCompanyofCoopers1596LUNA-FolgerSTC26018-gules&sablegyronny,etc.png WorshipfulCompanyofCoopers-gules&sablegyronny,etc.png
The armes of all the cheife corporatons [sic] of England, 1596 English (LUNA: Folger Digital Image Collection, STC 26018) Modern rendition of coat of arms of the Guild of Coopers

Iberian:

1506-1509 Livro do Armeiro-Mor (Livre du Grand Armurier) http://www.vikinganswerlady.com/FTP_Files/1506-1509_Livro_do_Armeiro-Mor_Portugal.pdf

  • Maia Chefe (100v): Gules, an eagle sable.
Livro Armas Livro
Livro de Armeiro-Mor 1506-1509, blue on green, green on red, black on red, complexity count of 11, dog & wolf Armas de los Condes, BSB290, 1440-1550, argent on argent, sable on gules Livro do Armeiro-Mor, 1506-1509, f100v, Maia Chefe, Gules an eagle sable.

German/Dutch:

Regional Exceptions to the Rule of Tincture, Vol. 01 (German) - https://www.facebook.com/notes/sca-heraldry-chat/regional-exceptions-to-the-rule-of-tincture-vol-01/10150677670804203

Regional Exceptions to the Rule of Tincture, Vol. 02 (more German) - https://www.facebook.com/notes/sca-heraldry-chat/regional-exceptions-to-the-rule-of-tincture-vol-01/10150677670804203

Zurich Roll (http://www.vikinganswerlady.com/]][[@l.php|ZurichRoll/ numbers: 99, 185) File:Zurick-Mandach-99.jpg File:Zurick-Ezelmarx-185.jpg


Ordinaries

Zurich Roll (http://www.vikinganswerlady.com/]][[@l.php|ZurichRoll/ numbers: 99, 185) 

#385 zum Angen: Gules, a pale sable within a bordure or.

Sable, a lion Or and overall a bend gules. Sammelband, f179.

Gules, a fess sable charged with three plates. Sammeland, f192

Inanimate Charges

Bartenschlager Band 3, Hafen: Gules in base a cauldron sable lidded Or. http://www.stadtarchiv-schaffhausen.ch/Schaffhausen-Geschichte/Genealogie/Register/Bartenschlager_3/Hafen.html [[File:https://fbcdn-sphotos-c-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-xaf1/v/t1.0-9/10801834_10152772591619401_2615250110049767619_n.jpg?oh=141e6da17bc67fd32678cd6fbda2c584&oe=555837C1&gda=1432054133_934127e09c9238e78779179c37a96bf8|right|Swiss]]

Counterchanging

Per pale sable and gules, two roundels in fess counterchanged. 1475-1500 Wernigeroder Wappenbuch [BSB Cod.icon. 308 n, folio 207r]

From OSCAR trying to register a sun counterchanged: "There are a few cases of per pale gules and sable or per pale sable and gules with one or two charges of similar complexity:"

"There are also several examples of sable on gules, or counterchanged low contrast in German heraldry:"

https://oscar.sca.org//index.php?action=145&id=67003

From another OSCAR submission for a rose counterchanged: The above submission has images. To view them, see the URLs below:

  1. Per pale gules and sable, an eagle counterchanged, Siebmacher, https://oscar.sca.org/images/cImages/234/2017-10-21/17-35-54_nur1
  2. Per pale sable and gules, two hooks addorsed counterchanged, Siebmacher, https://oscar.sca.org/images/cImages/234/2017-10-21/17-35-54_nur2
  3. Per pale gules and sable, two arms counterchanged holding aloft a crown or, Siebmacher, https://oscar.sca.org/images/cImages/234/2017-10-21/17-35-54_nur3

Animate Charges

Bartenschlager Band 4, Keller: Sable, a man statant proper robed gules wearing a cap of maintenance gules and ermine, maintaining in dexter hand a key or, upon a trimount issuant from base vert.http://www.stadtarchiv-schaffhausen.ch/Schaffhausen-Geschichte/Genealogie/Register/Bartenschlager_4/Keller_2.html

Bartenschlager Band 4, Köchlin: Per fess per pale or and sable and gules, in chief a demi-man issuant from the fess line in a gown counterchanged, wearing a torse sable and or, maintaining in dexter hand a bunch of grapes Or, and in base a cauldron sable within a wreath vert. http://www.stadtarchiv-schaffhausen.ch/Schaffhausen-Geschichte/Genealogie/Register/Bartenschlager_4/K%C3%B6chlin.html

Bartenschlager Band 5, Neidhardt: Gules, a bear sejant erect sable maintaining a vase with three flowers argent. http://www.stadtarchiv-schaffhausen.ch/Schaffhausen-Geschichte/Genealogie/Register/Bartenschlager_5/Neidhardt.html

BSB

Harder Band 3, Gäschlin: Gules, a bear rampant contourney sable maintaining an orb azure banded gules and surmounted by a cross Or. http://www.stadtarchiv-schaffhausen.ch/Schaffhausen-Geschichte/Genealogie/Register/Harder_3/G%C3%A4schlin.html

Gules, an eagle rising wings displayed sable armed or. Sammelband, f13.

Gules, a stag trippant sable crowned or. Sammelband, f26.

Gules, a bear rampant sable crowned or. Sammelband, f33.

Gules, an eagle sable. Sammelband, f150.

Gules, in pale a tower argent and an eagle sable (in base?). Sammelband, f152r.

Gules, a pile invected sable. Sammelband, f153.

Gules, an eagle sable crowned and maintaining two annulets in its claws Or. Sammelband, f158


Gules, in fess a tree proper sustained by a hairy Caucasion man furred and crined sable. Sammelband, f202

Image of OSCAR examples courtesy of Gunnvor silfrahar

From OSCAR - "The demonstration of a complex gules primary charge on a sable field is found in the following German armorial examples:

https://oscar.sca.org//index.php?action=145&id=41148

Trimounts:

  1. Siebmacher - Die Rothen, Sable an eagle rising wings displayed argent upon a trimount gules
  2. Siebmacher - V. Hinsperg, Gules, a demi (looks like a gazelle or goat) or issuant from a trimount sable
  3. Siebmacher - Schwartzenburg, Quarterly 1,4 Paly azure and argent, 2,3 Gules, a tower argent upon a trimount sable
  4. Manesse Codex - Johann von Ringgenberg, Gules, in pale a D-shaped buckle tongue to chief and a tri-mount couped sable
  5. Swiss Armorial - Röthlisberger (dated to 1392) Sable, a latin cross argent issuant from a trimount gules between in chief two mullets of six points Or.
  6. BSB392d Suddeutchland Armorial, 16th cent - Sable, a griffin argent issuant from a trimount gules.
  7. BSB392d Suddeutchland Armorial, 16th cent. - Sable, a mullet Or issuant from a trimount gules.

Großes Wappenbuch

Großes Wappenbuch, enthaltend die Wappen der deutschen Kaiser, der europäischen Königs- und Fürstenhäuser, der Päpste und Kardinäle, Bischöfe und Äbte bis zu den lebenden Repräsentanten zur Zeit der Regentschaft Kaiser Rudolfs II. und Papst Gregors XIII. - Cod.icon. 333 [S.l.] Süddeutschland 1583 - http://codicon.digitale-sammlungen.de/Blatt_bsb00002481,00006.html (collected by Gunnvor silfrahar)

Wagrien: Gules a bull's head affronty sable armed and ringed Or.

BSB333Grossesf8SableBull1583.JPG

Top row, third (can't read the name): {Blazoning only quarters 2 & 3} Sable a cross bottony gules.

BSB333Grossesf34GulesCrossesBottonyl1583.JPG

Cardinal Jullianus Cesarini: Gules, a column argent in front of a dog sable chained to the column argent. BSB333Grossesf44SableDog1583.JPG
(Can't Read Name): {Blazoning only quarter 2} Per fess or and sable, in chief a demi-lion issuant from the line of division sable crowned argent and in base a chevron indented and masoned gules. BSB333Grossesf88GulesChevron1583.JPG (No Name): {Blazoning only the very bottom left} Gules, an antler fesswise sable. BSB333Grossesf139rSableAntler1583.JPG (No Name): {Blazoning only the very bottom right} Sable, an antler fesswise gules. BSB333Grossesf140GulesAntler 1583.JPG
Lüdoüicus Cardinal und Bischoff: {Blazoning quarters 1 & 4 only} Argent, an eagle displayed sable semy of torteaux, armed and haloed Or. BSB333Grossesf115SableEagleSpottedGules 1583.JPG

Possibly also: Cardinalis de Comitibus pg. 173 and 228 Dns. Nicolaus archiepiscopus Gnesnensis in regno Poloine. pg. 179 Dns. Hainricus Civitatensis episcopus. pg. 225.

Italian:

Isignia Insignia
Isignia Venetorum nobilium II - BSB Cod.icon. 272 f25r - Italian 1550-1555 Insignia Lucensium, BSB278 f12r, 16th cent Italian, sable on azure, gules on sable?
BSB277InsigniaFlorentinorum_Cicciaporci_gules-sable_pigs-annulo.jpg BSB276InsigniaVeronensiumf54ScaltriellaSableChief.JPG BSB272p360-Gradenigi-boarstairs-gules-sable.png
BSB277 Insignia Florentinorum, Cicciaporci arms, sable on gules, pigs in annulo vs. on a bordure, sable on gules BSB276 Insignia Nobilium Veronensium... f54, Scaltriella family, sable chief on gules Insignia Venetorum, BSB 272 f360, 1550-55, stairway with sable boar on gules field

File:Italian low contrast3 primaries&secondaries.jpg

Eastern Europe:

Samogitia, Lithuania: Gules, a bear rampant sable collared argent. http://samogitia.mch.mii.lt/ISTORIJA/herbas.en.htm

Telšiai County, Lithuania: Gules, a bear rampant sable collared argent within a bordure azure semy of orthodox crosses Or. http://www.ldm.lt/VPG/Heraldika_1.htm

Vilniaus County, Lithuania: Gules, an armored knight maintaining a spear argent tipped Or and on a shield azure an orthodox cross Or, sejant upon a horse sable furnished azure, within a bordure azure semy of orthodox crosses Or. http://www.ldm.lt/VPG/Heraldika_1.htm


Previous Registration:

April 2010 Atlantia Letter of Intent for Murienne l'aloiere - New Device

http://oscar.sca.org/index.php?action=145&id=13410 OSCAR finds the name registered exactly as it appears in April of 2010, via Atlantia [under the old Rules for Submission] Gules, three furisons sable. As submitted, the device is in violation of the section of the Society's rules which require that "The field must have good contrast with every charge placed directly on it and with charges placed overall."

The submitter requests that this design, which incorporates three sable non-ordinary charges on a gules field, be considered as a "documented exception" to that requirement under the section of the rules which states that "a proposed exceptional armorial design element may be documented as characteristic of a specific regional armorial style." Under this rubric, current policy requires that the submitted armory may be registered provided that three very specific conditions are met. As any request for a "regional style" exemption tends to get complex fairly quickly, we will attempt to render the argument a bit more comprehensible by taking each of those conditions separately.

The submitter explicitly requests an exception to the other sections of Part VIII (Compatible Armorial Style) on the grounds that the submitted armory exemplifies a specific regional style. The submitter, verbally and in writing through her submitting herald, has specifically requested a "regional style" variance to the Society's contrast requirements.

These requirements are outlined in Part VIII of the Rules for Submission so are specifically eligible for a "documented exception". In point of fact, this is conceptually unexceptional as the original registration of a vert trimount on an azure field which set the ground rules for the current approach to "regional style" exceptions as well as a majority of the "regional style" exceptions granted in the years since have been exceptions to the contrast rules.

The submitter and her herald indicated that they believe that a pattern of sable charges on a gules field is documented from German heraldry which seemed to most commenters an adequately specific "regional armorial style" for the purposes of this requirement. It should perhaps be noted that one commenter with a particular interest in the armory of the German-speaking world as well as eastern Europe noted that a number of the examples originally used in support of the submission "were from Silesia and Austria, which altho' they are German-speaking, are only partially in the German heraldic area". In support of this argument, he provided an article entitled "The Heraldic Provinces of Europe" by Christopher von Warnstedt (The Coat of Arms XI [84]) which notes four primary heraldic "provinces": a "German-Nordic" province which includes Germany, the Scandinavian countries, the Baltic states and north and central Switzerland, a "French-British" province that included north and middle France and the British Isles, a "Latin" province that includes the south of France, Spain, Portugal and Italy, and an "Eastern European Province" which includes Croatia, Hungary, Poland, Lithuania, Russia and Rumania. In addition to this von Warnstedt noted "Border Districts" like Flanders, Bohemia-Moravia, Silesia, etc.

This article is actually very useful for our purposes as von Warnstedt notes that "it might be said that the heraldic system reached its most perfect form - if one prefers its greatest exaggerations - within the French-British province (II) and the border district of Flanders-Brabant-Holland." As this bias rather closely matches those of our traditional reliance on Anglo-Norman armorial traditions, his observations on the stylistic traditions of period Europe are rather useful in evaluating period style.

And, in point of fact, we feel that his observations support our interpretation that a broader view of the German heraldic sphere is reasonable in terms of an appeal to a specific regional style. Not only does he include the Scandinavian countries, the Baltic states and north and central Switzerland in addition to Germany in the "German-Nordic" province, but he also specifically states that Silesia mainly belongs to that province and notes that "the East European coats of arms which appear have often been altered in the German fashion".

Moreover, there appears to have been a rather strong tradition in Society armory of defining armorial regions in the context of "regional style" variations in a broader context (e.g., Iberian armory, German armory) rather than a narrower sphere (e.g., armory from German-speaking Switzerland, Silesian armory), armorial regions that are often defined as much by period or near-period sources available as by other conventions. In other words, there has been a strong tendency to consider all armory appearing in the seventeenth-century Siebmacher Wappenbuch and similar works as coming from a single, reasonably coherent regional style that we tend to refer to generically as "German".

Documentation is adduced to show that exceptional design element was not uncommon in the regional style in question. Examples of similarly complex non-ordinary charges in sable on a gules field abound in German armory. To take only a few readily available examples:

I On side 11v of a manuscript catalogued and digitized by the Bavarian State Library under the name Wappen deutscher Geschlechter, which contains the bound manuscript BSB Hss. Cod.icon. 311, dated to the fourth quarter of the fifteenth century and believed to derive from the vicinity of Augsburg, one can find a coat which shows "Gules, a hat sable brimmed Or." (http://daten.digitale-sammlungen.de/bsb00001650/image_26).

  • Sable on gules and gules on sable can even be found in a counterchange! On side 34r of a manuscript catalogued and digitized by the Bavarian State Library under the name Tirol, Anton: Wappenbuch , which contains the bound manuscript BSB Hss. Cod.icon. 310, dated to the end of the fifteenth century and believed to derive from southern Germany, one can find a coat which shows "Per pale gules and sable, a wagon wheel counterchanged." (http://daten.digitale-sammlungen.de/bsb00001649/image_73). Note that the precise values for the tinctures involved guarantee that this is not a case where original argent metallics have darkened to an apparent sable as has been known to happen in certain heraldic manuscripts!

Since Laurel precedent on "regional style" has tended to be strongly conservative in determining when examples of armory from a particular armorial tradition are similarly simple or complex as compared to a submitted item, it seemed to us advisable to offer as well examples where the complexity of a design goes beyond a single primary charge to involve two or three predominantly or entirely sable charges on a gules field.

  • Von Geffen ("Gules, in fess two horns sable.") from Plate 52 of Johann Siebmacher's Wappenbuch published in 1605 (http://www.wappenbuch.de/pages/wappen_52_Siebmacher.htm).
  • The arms of the poet Wolfram von Eschenbach, as shown on side 149v of the Manesse Codex (online at http://digi.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/diglit/cpg848/0294) have often been blazoned as "Gules, two cleavers addorsed sable." (see, for example, Coblaith's article "Shields and Escutcheons in the Manesse Codex" online at http://coblaith.net/Heraldry/Manesse/shieldstable2.html).
  • The arms of Johann von Ringgenberg, as shown on side 149v of the Manesse Codex (online at http://digi.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/diglit/cpg848/0376) can be blazoned as "Gules, in pale a D-shaped buckle tongue to chief and a tri-mount couped sable." (see, for example, Coblaith's article "Shields and Escutcheons in the Manesse Codex" online at http://coblaith.net/Heraldry/Manesse/shieldstable2.html).
  • Die Aver von Tobel ("Gules, in pale three horns fesswise reversed sable.") from Plate 80 of Johann Siebmacher's Wappenbuch published in 1605 (http://www.wappenbuch.de/pages/wappen_80_Siebmacher.htm).
  • On side 97v of a manuscript catalogued and digitized by the Bavarian State Library under the name Tirol, Anton: Wappenbuch , which contains the bound manuscript BSB Hss. Cod.icon. 310, dated to the end of the fifteenth century and believed to derive from southern Germany, one can find a coat which shows "Per fess gules and argent, three mullets of six points counterchanged sable and gules." (http://daten.digitale-sammlungen.de/bsb00001649/image_200). (Note that, while the field is an evenly divided tincture, two of the three mullets are sable on a gules field and the overall arrangement of the charges is two and one as in the submitted device.)
  • On side 74r of a manuscript catalogued and digitized by the Bavarian State Library under the name Wappenbuch - BSB Cod.icon. 392 d, which contains the bound manuscript BSB Hss. Cod.icon. 392d, dated to the first half of the sixteenth century and believed to derive from southern Germany, one can find a coat which shows "Gules, three Moor's heads contourny sable, heads bound with scarves argent." (http://daten.digitale-sammlungen.de/bsb00018706/image_215).

Documentation is adduced to show that all elements of the submitted armory can be found in the regional style in question. The specific sable on gules issue for which the submitter petitions an exception has been addressed above. Internal commentary was able to provide support for the appearance of the furison (in modern German blazon appearing as Feuerstahl) within the German sphere of influence:

  • The arms of Grassauer, which can be blazoned "Gules, a furison argent." appear clearly in the Zurich Roll on Strip II Back Page 8 which can be found reproduced in full at http://www.silverdragon.org/HERALDRY/ZurichRolls/zroadt2r.htm. The arms also appear in a detail clip on the Viking Answer Lady website at http://www.vikinganswerlady.com/ZurichRoll. (The original of the Zurich Roll is generally dated by internal evidence to the middle of the fourteenth century, making it one of the earliest Continental rolls of arms, and the copy from which the digitized images are derived appears to date from the sixteenth century.)
  • On side 44v of a manuscript catalogued and digitized by the Bavarian State Library under the name Wappen deutscher Geschlechter, which contains the bound manuscript BSB Hss. Cod.icon. 311, dated to the fourth quarter of the fifteenth century and believed to derive from the vicinity of Augsburg, one can find a coat which shows "Or, a furison sable." (http://daten.digitale-sammlungen.de/bsb00001650/image_92).
  • On side 26r of a manuscript likewise catalogued and digitized by the Bavarian State Library under the name Sammelband mehrerer Wappenbücher, which contains the bound manuscript BSB Cod.icon. 391, dated to around 1530 and believed to derive from the vicinity of Augsburg, one can find a coat which shows "Or, a cross between four furisons azure." (http://daten.digitale-sammlungen.de/bsb00007681/image_53).

Most telling, however, in documenting the use of the furison or Feuerstahl in period German armory is an article by Ottfried Neubecker entitled "Die Bedeutung von Feuerstahl und Feuerstein, den Gliedern das Kette des Ordens vom goldenen Vlies" in Volume II of Estudios genealógicos, heráldicos y nobiliarios en honor de Vicente de Cadenas y Vicent (pp. 73ff., which are available on line at http://books.google.com/books?id=utOmTtZlzt8C&pg=PA73&lpg=PA73&dq=Die+Bedeutung+von+Feuerstahl+und+Feuerstein,+den+Gliedern+das+Kette+des+Ordens+vom+goldenen+Vlies&source=bl&ots=u9T0wcPsoE&sig=LPrNIAi-RyBjB3wubt4l9o0fU5I&hl=en&ei=AJvZS_HlEIPA8wSJoPRN&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=3&ved=0CBEQ6AEwAg#v=onepage&q&f=false). There he notes that the charge appears in the armory of a family In der alten Münze or de Moneta at Strassburg as early as 1334 and possibly as early as 1266 (pp. 74-75). From 1334 as well he notes the arms of Grassauer cited above as well as those of Grebel and Henning von Wodenswegen as containing the charge (p.75). On the same page he notes several families who bore the charge in canting arms, including a German family Stahl who bore "Or, a furison sable.", a Tirolian-Bavarian family Schurff who bore "Azure, a furison Or." and a family by the name of Schurfeisen who bore "Gules, a furison argent.". Neubecker also notes Wilhelm Schurg, an official of the court of the emperor Maximilian I (1459-1519), who used a furison in both his arms and his crest. Not to belabor the point, we will cite only a few more specifically dated examples of armory bearing a furison cited by Neubecker from the German sphere of influence: Johann Schurf or Schurpf from Constance in 1414 who bore "Argent, a sable furison."(p. 76), Konrad Groppenstein from Schöneck 1360-1377 who bore "Gules, a furison argent.") and Konrad Herr in 1584 who bore "Sable, a furison Or."

Taken together, we feel that this evidence not only supports the view that the furison or Feuerstahl occurred in German armory, but may even have been not uncommon for canting arms, given the variety of tincture combinations in which we have found it occurring. Device Comments:

  • Someone was concerned that the documentation supported Gules, a <charge> sable, and Gules, two <charges> sable but not Gules, three <charges> sable, unfortunately. They indicated they had seen in period rolls a lot of the first motif, a few of the second, and even Per pale gules and sable, an eagle counterchanged, but not three charges on the field in this color scheme and arrangement...
  • Someone else noted that the documentation included Gules, three Moor's heads contourny sable, heads bound with scarves argent and Gules, in pale three horns fesswise reversed sable. It also included Per fess gules and argent, three mullets of six points counterchanged sable and gules.
  • Also Johann Siebmacher's Wappenbuch von 1605, p.193 illus 173, Ritterschaft und Adel in Meissen: Lampen: Gules three lamps sable.
Retrieved from "http://scaheraldry.info/index.php?title=Gules_and_Sable&oldid=7351"